Talk About Blyton!
|December 1, 2017: Faraway Tree - Concept Similarities
Do you think the concept of the lands at the top of the Faraway Tree is very like Rod Serling's The Twilight Zone? —Paul
|November 17, 2017: Famous Five - Why do the Five change their name to Barnard from Kirrin?
I always wondered what Julian, Dick and Annes' surname was? I remember in Five Get Into A Fix that their mother was referred to as Mrs Barnard. But I am sure they were all introduced as Kirrins in another book. Any thoughts? —David
|Daisy says: You are right, about their surname being mentioned as Barnard, but I think they were intended as Kirrins. This discussion has come up many times especially on the Enid Blyton Society forums
Fatty says: We have moved this topic to the relevant thread, as it has been discussed here.
|November 12, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Spin offs you would like to see?
In the old Blyton Live Journal community, someone said they could see June be very good as a criminal or black marketeer. I might write that story one day. —Paul
|November 6, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Spin offs you would like to see?
Sorry, there was a mistake in the previous text. The correct one is: Jo Falls into Adventure. 'Five Fall into Adventure' told in first person by Jo. Regards felix. —Felix
|Buster says: Apologies, I'm still getting used to typing with my paws.|
|November 6, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Spin offs you would like to see?
Jo from Fall into Adventure. 'Five Fall into Adventure' told in first person by Jo. —Felix
|Buster says: I guess it would be something different, but unlikely to happen.|
|November 3, 2017: Malory Towers - Is there really a boarding school on the Cornwall coast?
A great fan of Enid Blyton and her books, check out the link- [link removed] It proved jolly useful for me, and maybe for you too. —Samridhi
|Fatty says: These are illegal downloads. The site says that these books are in the public domain. Books are not in the public domain until 70 years after the author's death. In Enid's case, this won't be until 2038. The website owners should know this. Illegal downloading is theft. Please ensure that you post in the correct thread, as this has nothing to do with the location of Malory Towers.|
|November 3, 2017: Malory Towers - How do you rate Malory Towers?
Hi, I am Samridhi. I am twelve and I have read the whole Malory Towers series, beginning to end, including the ones by Pamela Cox too. And my, like Felicity and her form got very solemn and sad in the end, I too got very solemn and sad indeed. I know there's no school like Malory Towers in reality, but how I wish there was. This is my favorite series ever, and is there any film or TV series on Malory Towers? Well, I wanted to ask that as Pamela continues the series for Felicity, can't someone continue it for Daffy, with someone from Darell's family and one from Alicia's? Well, I am trying my best to continue it myself!! —Samridhi
|Fatty says: Good luck! I have moved your post to a more appropriate thread.|
|November 3, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Holidays
I don't think it's a case of being "un-PC", Avan, it's just an out-of-date term. A bit like referring to a home-help as a char lady. Housemaids, kitchenmaids, scullerymaids were often very young, and were maids - the old term for young single girls. —Nigel
|October 27, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Holidays
I also did not know that it is un PC to say maid for a home helper these days till I read the above post. Glad to learn this and will bear it in mind. . All persons do not have the same capabilities and each one has his own special ability which is deserving of appreciation and none should be considered superior or inferior. —Avan N. Cooverji
|October 21, 2017: Famous Five - Bloopers?
Hey guys Famous Five 21 (Five are together again), it's mentioned that George always waits for term end as Timmy stays at home but in all the earlier novels, he went to school with George and in the second book Gerige herself said that she wouldn't go to school of Timmy wasn't allowed. They haven't mentioned the school rules being changed and George wouldn't just accept it. I would be glad of any clarity provided. —Nandita
|Fatty says: Yes, most odd. It was written when Enid had become ill, so maybe she just forgot.|
|October 11, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Ghost writers
I am surprised, since I have never heard of such a thing that a book may be published under the name of another author, having the same book cover design and even her name written the same way on the cover as on other 'original' books and that at the same time it may have another author. I cannot believe it that copywright laws allow someone, even a company to publish something under the name of someone who cannot give permission to this anymore. Not that I have investigated it though. But obviously, I feel misled anyway. —Melinda TURI
|Fatty says: It is quite common. There is a series of adult books based on the Famous Five, called Enid Blyton for Grown Ups. Click on the link to see one of them. Many Blyton fans strongly disagree with this, but Hodder have obviously given their approval.|
|October 10, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Ghost writers
My daugther started reading her books. The first one was The secret island. She loved it and we could hardly get enough books for her in English. So I was happy to find lots of her books in second hand book shops as we arrived to Germany. We reread The Secret Island in German which not only has a different title,but the translators stupefied the story,making lots of changes in it. However, my shock came today,when my daughter came home from the library with 6 Enid Blyton books from the series of 'Fünf Freunde'(five friends) and inside the cover it says with tiny letters that they have been authored by Sarah Bosse! How can that happen? —Melinda TURI
|Daisy says: I'm baffled, Melinda. Unless someone has done continuation stories of Enid's books? Maybe someone reading this posting can shed light on this.
Fatty says: I don't think there's any mystery here to solve, Melinda. Sarah Bosse has written 30 Famous Five (Fünf Freunde) follow-on books for the German market. Your daughter has simply borrowed six of those.
|October 9, 2017: Naughtiest Girl - Naughtiest Girl Comic adaptation in Pixie Comic 1972 - illustrator?
Hello, I'm wondering whether anyone remembers or has any information concerning the illustrator of the fantastic Enid Blyton adaptation, 'The Story of The Naughtiest Girl in The School', which appeared in Pixie comic in 1972? The strip first appeared in the very first issue of Pixie, June 24th 1972. It truly is a fabulous strip and the artwork really captures the spirit of the story, but I can't find the illustrator's name anywhere and it's really bugging me! This artist deserves recognition for his/her amazing work! Can anyone help? —Dylan
|Fatty says: I believe Eric Parker might have illustrated some of these, Dylan. However, the Enid Blyton Society states that the illustrator is uncredited.|
|October 4, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - What EB book would make the perfect movie?
I wish someone would make proper "just like the books" films or TV series of all the Famous Fives. The two series they made were ok, but I would like visuals that looked like Eileen Soper had been on set, locations that looked like the descriptions in the books, and as few plot deviations as possible. There's obviously the danger that things might get a bit repetitive as the stories progress, but I think it could be done. —Paul Austin
|Fatty says: Like this, Paul? :-)|
|October 3, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Why update books?
Love rereading Enid Blyton. Was brought up in India in the 70s and Enid Blyton was our window into another totally different, yet delightful world. Firmly against any editing at all. Affects the way we remember the book. What right does anyone gave to change another person's work without their permission? —Lalitha Manjunath
|September 20, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Thoughts, Ramblings and Essays
I think it is very interesting how certain ideas about some groups were accepted as THE TRUTH at that time and how that is reflected even in childrens fiction. It just goes to show truth is more changeable, less universal than we might think and maybe even illusory in some respects. The whole idea of there being such a thing as THE TRUTH begins to be called into question and I think the Famous Five would have found that very difficult. —Sarah Strong
|Fatty says: Hmm. That takes some thinking about. Not sure what you mean by "some groups". What do you mean by "THE TRUTH"?|
|September 15, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Holidays in Blyton Locations
Quite a lot of Enid Blytons books were written during the second world war or during the prolonged period of rationing that followed. How tantalising the feasts in her books would have been to children who had to endure a very restricted diet, with limited protein and few sweet treats! —Sarah Strong
|September 15, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Enid's Desciption of Foreigners
Sorry to add a slight complication but whether you regard Enid Blyton as racist or not may depend somewhat on which edition of her books you have read. Over the years many of her books have had the attentions of editors who have altered the text to make it less harsh towards certain groups. One example of this is the references to the Oriental foreigners that capture the children in The Mountain of Adventure. Some of the original text seemed painfully prejudiced to me. However, and much as I love the books, it isn't just different races that are affected. Women and girls dont exactly come in for fair and equal treatment. Georg(e)(ina) in the Famous Five, despite being intelligent, courageous, athletic and consistantly honest,( even when it will get her into trouble), only counts as being " nearly as good as a boy, " and the way that Julian leaps in and takes control during a crisis, despite a female adult being present and the way he speaks to and about her and talks to others, such as the police, (and I am thinking particularly but not exclusively of Aunt Fanny,) in her presence, gives the impression that adult females are a load of witless idiots too unintelligent or incapable with nervous complaints to determine a sensible course of action. If you want to consider whether Enid Blyton was prejudiced, the clearest view will be found by studying the earlier texts, as the later ones have been edited. —Sarah Strong
|Fatty says: Blyton wrote in an era where girls were treated differently to boys. They were seen as the weaker sense. By updating these stories the historical aspect of the books are lost. They should be read as the classics that they are. You'd hardly expect to read of Jane Eyre wearing jeans or Tom Brown not getting the cane at school, would you?|
|September 14, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Spin offs you would like to see?
How about June Johns running a detective agency? —Paul Austin
|September 13, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Holidays
Sadly, Daisy, it's un PC to call a female home help a "maid" now. We're told to use "housekeeper" as the home help can be male these days. —Paul Austin
|Daisy says: I was using the word "maid" as in Blyton times, not these times, Paul!|
|September 9, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Holidays
Daisy, the holidays I wrote about were during very different times, then things were very affordable , we were simple middle class families, and there was nothing exotic about these breaks. And family in those times meant not only a single unit of mother , father and their children but also extended families like aunts and uncles and grandparents and cousins. Even very close friends were considered family as were very close neighbours. And all went together on holidays and when the cost was shared, it worked out very economically. So in case I have given an idea of something expensive and grand and exclusive, nothing could be further from that. Also a cook was essential to help with such a large group and the ladies all worked in tandem with the cook. Everyone pitched in to do everything together. But why are you surprised on the mention of a cook being present? In Enid Blyton's Five FindOuters series , Pip and Bets have a cook , Fatty has a cook and they have maids as well, that too live- in maids , besides they have garderners and all sort of help and that too on a regular basis. So it is a bit difficult for me to understand why you find it out of the ordianry to find people take a cook along with them and that too for the short duration of a holiday period. —Avan N. Cooverji
|Daisy says: Your holidays with family and friends, sound wonderful, Avan. Sadly I wasn't in the same era and things like a maid and a cook just wasn't affordable. One of the reasons why I personally love to read about - cooks and a maid - in the Blyton books.|
|September 9, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Holidays
Holidays! I remember how exciting it was as a child to hear the family make holiday plans. There would be first the decision to be made on where to go for a holiday, then the planning of an itenary, then the booking of train tickets, finally the packing and on the long awaited day, off we went. These were the days when it would never be a break of 3 nights-4 days but a proper holiday of at least a month. But those were affordable times, sometimes we would book a bungalow on rent for a full month, the family would also take along a cook hired for the duration of that month, and the amount of bags and baggages we would have with us! And it was always with reluctance that we returned back to the city and already we would be planning for our next holiday. —Avan N. Cooverji
|Daisy says: Gosh that was a long holiday, Avan. We were lucky as kids if we got a week. And we never had the money to take along a cook!|
|September 3, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Holidays
If I won the lottery, I'd invest in research to cure cancer, diabetes etc. —Paul
|August 27, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Holidays
If I were to win an exceptional lottery and there is no limitation to money to be spent on a holiday, I would book my husband and myself for a World Cruise on a luxury Ocean Liner. It would be first class all the way with the best accomodation available , the best gourmet food, all luxury suites and cars for sightseeing at ports of call. I would take full advantage of the beauty salons and massage parlours and other facilities available on board. I would call for room service for every little thing were I to feel too lazy to step outside my stateroom. I would also take along a maid for me , a valet for my husband and a secretary for both of us who would handle all the nitty gritty and make all travel and other arrangements for us. In short, I would not exert myself to do a thing but would be the Queen and make my husband the King of all we survey! —Avan N. Cooverji
|Fatty says: As you posted in the Holidays in Blyton Locations thread, I have moved this to the generel Holidays thread, Avan.|
|August 26, 2017: Unlisted - Enid Blyton in general - Holidays
Ofcourse, Fatty says only as a joke that Welsh people should come to Peterswood for change of air, but truly Peterswood is such a nice peaceful and lovely village that anyone who has any health issues or even other problems would soon forget their ills and become happy and stong again. I for one woud love to have lived there, can anyone tell me where Peterswood is in England today? —Anonymous
|Fatty says: It is thought to be based on Bourne End, in Buckinghamshire - especially around Coldmoorholme Lane, where Enid used to live.|